Cart 0

Cheese Shop & Cave Aging Facility

Old Brooklyn Cheese Co. opened its doors in December 2016. We are the only brick & mortar cheese shop in Cleveland, OH and one of two licensed cheese makers in Cuyahoga County. Our cheese production & cave aging facility is directly below our cheese shop. Hartzler Family Dairy in Wooster, OH, supplies us with Non-GMO certified milk for our raw milk cheeses. All of our cheeses are cave aged for a minimum of 60 days.

Our shop has over 100 local, domestic, & imported cheeses available. A variety of cured meats, baguettes, jams, honeys, crackers, olives, pickles, olive oils, vinegars, local drinks are available to create your ultimate cheese & charcuterie board.

We have two communal tables in the front of our shop to enjoy sandwiches and cheese & charcuterie tasting boards.

Need Gift Ideas?


We have gift certificates available in any denomination. You can also send an egift card instantly with Giftfly.

At our shop we can create a birthday or special occasion cake made of cheese.

For the ultimate cheese lovers we have created tiered wheels of cheese for wedding cakes and large group events.


Our Mustard

Shop Now

ITRX3413 (1).JPG

Cheese Platters

Shop Now


Cheese Tastings & Sandwiches